by Sister Autumn
"We wanted somebody who was blue-collar,
former cop, a man's man."
-- Chris Carter on John Doggett, Television Critics Association
"What's more important is that he's as different
from Mulder as we could make him."
-- Chris Carter on John Doggett, Cinescape Magazine
This summer and fall, in advance of some big changes to the show for season 8, 1013 launched a campaign. Let's call it the "John Manly Mannish Blue-Collar Guyness Doggett Campaign." For some reason they have become oddly fixated on the perceived masculinity of this new character. And they want to tell us about it. Over and over and over. Just so we know without question that this guy is exceedingly manly. Apparently Scully was paired with David Duchovny's character Denise from Twin Peaks the past seven years since to hear them talk Mulder was, I don't know, a girlie man? A squirrel's guy? A white-collar slacker wussy?
"He's a masculine presence.
He has more of a blue-collar, working man quality."
-- Frank Spotnitz, Palm Beach Post
This all got me to thinking. What if Scully had been paired with His Manliness since the beginning of the series? Just what could such a masculine presence bring to some of the classic exchanges between the agents? Would there be Doggettisms? If so I think they may have gone a little like this...
| THE PILOT |
| Doggett: |
You lost nine minutes! Me, I never get lost.
|
DARKNESS FALLS |
| Scully: |
What am I looking at? |
| Doggett: |
Thirty loggers working a clear-cutting contract in Washington State. Rugged, manly men in the full bloom of their manhood. Much like myself. |
"Robert's got a very masculine quality."
-- Chris Carter, Entertainment Weekly
| TOOMS |
| Doggett: |
If there's a Budweiser in that bag, it could be your lucky night. |
SYZYGY |
| Scully: |
I'm driving. Why do you always have to drive? Because you're the guy? Because you're the big macho man? |
| Doggett: |
Yes. |
ONE BREATH |
| Doggett: |
(to Scully at her beside) WAKE UP ALREADY I'M BORED! |
"Doggett is really a guy's guy."
-- Frank Spotnitz, X-Files Official Magazine
| NEVER AGAIN |
| Scully: |
Why don't I have a desk? |
| Doggett: |
Because you're the secretary? |
PAPER CLIP |
| Scully: |
I've heard the truth, Doggett. Now what I want are the answers. |
| Doggett: |
Well if you quit being such a big baby we could find them. So your sister's dead. Welcome to the club. |
IRRESISTIBLE |
| Scully: |
It took us 3 hours to get here, our plane doesn't leave until tomorrow night. If you suspected . . . |
| Doggett: |
The Rock versus Stone Cold Steve Austin, Scully. Ringside. You and me. |
"He is a man's man, an ex-cop,
and he's got that kind of edge."
-- Gillian Anderson, LA Magazine
| ONE SON |
| Scully: |
You tell me that Cassandra Spender is the critical test subject
- the one who could prove everything. And yet, who is watching over her? Doggett, I can prove what you're saying or I can disprove it but not when Diana Fowley is keeping us from even seeing her. Doggett, ask yourself why there is no information whatsoever on Special Agent Diana Fowley. Why she would suddenly happen into your life when you are closer than ever to the truth. I mean, you ... you ask me to trust no one and yet you trust her on simple faith. |
| Doggett: |
Is it that time of the month already? |
WETWIRED |
| Scully: |
It's not the truth, Mom. He's lied to me from the beginning. He never trusted me. |
| Doggett: |
Well, you are a woman. |
ARCADIA |
| Doggett: |
Woman, get back in here and make me a sandwich! |
"He's like one of the "guys,"
he's like one of the hard-core there
... he's his own man. "
-- Chris Carter at Comic-Con
| THE MOVIE |
| Doggett: |
What's wrong this time? |
| Scully: |
Salt Lake City, Utah. Transfer effective immediately. I already gave Skinner my letter of resignation. |
| Doggett: |
Quitter. |
| Scully: |
I debated whether or not even to tell you in person, but . . . |
| Doggett: |
I am close to something here! I'm on the verge! |
| Scully: |
You're on the verge, Doggett. Oh, you just said that. |
| Doggett: |
Fine, just walk away. Typical. |
| Scully: |
You don't need me, Doggett. You never have. I've just held you back . . . I gotta go. |
| Doggett: |
True, but you do look great in a skirt. |
| Scully: |
Why did they assign me to you in the first place, Doggett? To debunk your work, to rein you in, to shut you down . . . |
| Doggett: |
Did the skirt comment count for nothing? |
"Doggett's a male." -- Robert Patrick, New York Times
|

The Manly Cop Song
by Sister 'Dubh
INT. An FBI office. Enter DOGGETT, backed by a chorus of Manly Men in Manly suits, incl. SKINNER, KRYCEK, X, and KERSH, but not SPENDER JR.
DOGGETT (sings):
I'm a manly cop and I'm ok,
I drink all night and I grunt all day.
CHORUS:
He's a manly cop and he's ok,
He drinks all night and he grunts all day
DOGGETT:
I run down crooks, I drink lite beer,
I go to the lavatr'y,
On Sundays I drive racecars,
And my face stays scrunchy-free!
CHORUS:
He runs down crooks,
He drinks lite beer,
He goes to the lavatr'y,
On Sundays he drives racecars,
And his face stays scrunchy-free!
He's a manly cop and he's ok,
He drinks all night and he grunts all day
DOGGETT:
I run down crooks, I shred X-files,
I never lose my gun.
I'd need it if they found out,
Scully kicks my ass for fun!
CHORUS:
He runs down crooks, he shreds X-files,
He'd never lose his gun.
He'd need it if they found out,
Scully kicks his ass for fun?
He's a manly cop and he's ok,
He drinks all night and he grunts all day
DOGGETT:
I run down crooks, I'm Kersh's bitch,
CC's and Spotzie's too.
It says here in my contract,
RP can never sue!
CHORUS:
He runs down crooks,
He's Kersh's bitch,
CC and Spotzie's too?....
He's a manly cop and he's ok,
He drinks all night and he grunts all day
Enter SCULLY, who trips him and places a 3" heel on his chest.
Scully (scornfully):
"Oh John, and they told me you were so butch!"
|